Here, we’ll review the top 10 best diaper pails consumer reports on the market today. We’ll provide an overview of the pros and cons of each product. Read on for our selection of best diaper pails consumer reports.
In Hurry? Checkout Our Top Pick Of Best Diaper Pails Consumer Reports.
Our Top Pick
9.7/10 our score
Best Diaper Pails Consumer Reports
Rank | Product Name | Score |
---|---|---|
1 |
Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail |
9. 7 |
2 |
Dekor Classic Hands-Free Diaper Pail | White | Easiest to Use | Just Step – Drop – Done | Doesn’t Absorb Odors | 20 Second Bag Change | Most Economical Refill System |
9. 5 |
3 |
Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Powered by Arm & Hammer, Includes (1) Bonus Toss Disposable Diaper Pail |
9. 1 |
4 |
Careforbaby Diaper Pail Refill Bags (960 Counts) Fully Compatible with Arm&Hammer Disposal System - 32 Bags |
8. 8 |
5 |
Diaper Pail Refills for Diaper Genie and Munchkin Diaper Pails - 2160 Count - 8 Pack |
8. 6 |
6 |
Diaper Genie Playtex Complete Diaper Pail, with Built-in Odor Controlling Antimicrobial, Includes 1 Pail and 3 Max Fresh Refills, White Pail |
8. 2 |
7 |
Bubula Step Premium Steel & Aluminum Diaper Waste Pail with Air Tight Lid and Security Lock for Nursery or Any Room Use, White |
8. 0 |
8 |
Lil’ Jumbl Odor Locking Diaper Pail, Child-Proof Diaper Trash Can, Modern Sleek Design, Easy to Use & Clean, No Special Bag Required, Small Diaper Trash Can |
7 .7 |
9 |
Diaper Pail Refills Fit Dekor Plus Diaper Pails - Powder Scent - Holds 4640 Diapers - 8 Pack |
7. 4 |
10 |
Diaper Pail Refills Compatible with Diaper Genie Pails, Munchkin Step and Munchkin Pail,12 Pack |
7. 2 |
1. Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail
9.7/10 our score
- Easy 1 hand use
- Uses standard plastic bags
- Dorizer disc included, Replacement discs sold separately (23900), Warning: proposition 65 reasons: Titanium dioxide, other chemicals
2. Dekor Classic Hands-Free Diaper Pail | White | Easiest to Use | Just Step – Drop – Done | Doesn’t Absorb Odors | 20 Second Bag Change | Most Economical Refill System
9.5/10 our score
- Totally Hands-Free: Step, Drop, Done! No Bending, No Twisting, No Squishing, Unlike Ordinary Pails!
- Most Cost-Effective Diaper Pail Refill System on the Market. Dekor Refill System Creates Less Waste - Use ONLY What You Need!
- Effective Triple Odor Control Keeps the Smell in the Pail
- Award Winning Product Tested by Millions of Parents
- Closed-Cell ABS Plastic Works Like Metal but Won't Rust
- Use Only Genuine Dekor Refills with Exclusive End-of-Liner Marking
- Comes Completely Assembled with One Full-Sized (not a starter!) Refill Pre-Installed!
- Life After Diapers: Converts from Diaper Pail to Trash Can
3. Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Powered by Arm & Hammer, Includes (1) Bonus Toss Disposable Diaper Pail
9.1/10 our score
- Proven #1 in odor control, Step Diaper Pail keeps your nursery fresh
- Awarded 2020 Best Overall Diaper Pail by the Good Housekeeping Institute
- Patented self-sealing system keeps odors contained whether lid is open or closed
- The only diaper pail compatible with both Refill Rings and Snap, Seal & Toss Bags
- Set contains Step pail, Snap, seal and toss bag, Starter ring refill, Lavender scented baking soda puck and Toss disposable diaper pail
- Get a pail, give a tree. For every Step Diaper Pail sold, Munchkin will plant a tree
- Measures 27” high x 12” deep, Comes with step pedal to open hands-free
4. Careforbaby Diaper Pail Refill Bags (960 Counts) Fully Compatible with Arm&Hammer Disposal System - 32 Bags
8.8/10 our score
- Favorable Profits: Holds 960 diapers (up to 32 per bag) and cost less than a cent for each diaper.
- Easy Using: One-handed use. Just snap, seal and toss, no cutting or tying knots in the bags and double lace on the side and make sure it does not ripped.
- High Compatible: Fully Compatible with Arm & Hammer diaper pail.
- Friendly Material: Imported materials of highly flexible PE, thicken layer and double seam protection. Better in odor control.
- Package: Including 32 disposable refill bags that shut tight with a snap.
5. Diaper Pail Refills for Diaper Genie and Munchkin Diaper Pails - 2160 Count - 8 Pack
8.6/10 our score
- Compatible with Diaper Genie Expression, Diaper Genie Complete, Diaper Genie II, Diaper Genie II Elite, Diaper Genie Essentials and Mini.
- It is also compatible with Munchkin STEP and Munchkin PAIL
- Large Capacity: This compact refill comes with 2160 counts and holds up to 270 diapers
- Keep Odors Away: With unique barrier technology, each refill has the film to trap odors, making your home smell fresh and keep clean
- Cost Saving: Longer film in the cassette provide a more favorable cost for a longer lasting time
- Convenience for Daily Cleanup: No need to waste time to change garbage bag every day, giving you more time to stay with your babies
6. Diaper Genie Playtex Complete Diaper Pail, with Built-in Odor Controlling Antimicrobial, Includes 1 Pail and 3 Max Fresh Refills, White Pail
8.2/10 our score
- ALL IN ONE DIAPER PAIL - Diaper Genie’s ultimate diaper disposal system controls odors and makes changing your baby’s dirty diapers a breeze. Our tallest pail requires no bending with a foot pedal for easy, hygienic and hands-free opening.
- BUILT IN ANTIMICROBIAL - The pail & refill contain built-in antimicrobials to prevent germ spread! The pail includes built-in antimicrobial that inhibits bacteria growth while the Max Fresh refills contain a built-in odor controlling antimicrobial.
- KEEP YOUR NURSERY FRESH - Unlike other pails without clamps, the Complete Pail features Double Air-Tite Clamps that works with the 7-layer diaper pail refill bags and carbon filter to add a layer of double dooty odor protection.
- MASK DIRTY DIAPER ODORS - Max Fresh refills feature a new clean laundry scent to help neutralize strong diaper odors and keep your nursery smelling fresh. They also contain improved opaque film so you don't see dirty diapers when emptying the pail.
- #1 SELLING DIAPER PAIL - Over 1.5 million moms put their trust in Diaper Genie Complete for a fresher smelling nursery.
7. Bubula Step Premium Steel & Aluminum Diaper Waste Pail with Air Tight Lid and Security Lock for Nursery or Any Room Use, White
8/10 our score
- DURABLE CONSTRUCTION: All Steel and aluminum construction with taller base and ergonomic lid, making it easer to access, Measuring 11.3 x 11.3 x 28 inches
- NO ODORS: Air tight lid and rubber seal keeps prevents leaks and keeps unwanted odors locked inside
- STANDARD SIZE BAGS: Uses standard-size can liners, no need to purchase expensive custom bags
- SAFETY LOCK: Features a safety lock to keep container locked from children and spills
- VERSATILE: The Bubula diaper waste pail's unique and impressive design easily convents to a regular trash can for long term use in any room, Top lid opens with a foot pedal, enabling hands free operation, Attractive design will fit perfectly in any nursery or kids room
8. Lil’ Jumbl Odor Locking Diaper Pail, Child-Proof Diaper Trash Can, Modern Sleek Design, Easy to Use & Clean, No Special Bag Required, Small Diaper Trash Can
7.7/10 our score
- UNBELIEVABLE ODOR CONTROL | Unlike a Typical Trash Can, Our Diaper Bin is Made of 100% Leakproof Non-Porous Material & Features a Unique Open/Close Rotating Drum Pocket & Movable Handle | Turn Handle to Dump Soiled Diaper into the Bag, Lock Out Foul Odors & Prevent Children or Pets from Getting to the Pail’s Contents
- CHIC CONTEMPORARY DESIGN | The Bin Effortlessly Balances Form & Function with a Gorgeous Silhouette, Neutral White Color & Discreet, Compact Styling | The Perfect Complement to Your Modern Nursery, Bedroom, Bathroom or Daycare | Bags Are Also Easy to Remove & Replace Without Odors Escaping into the Room
- NO SPECIAL BAGS REQUIRED | Universal Refill System Securely Accommodates All Kinds of Popular Trash Bags Including Everyday Grocery Shopping Bags, Tall Kitchen Bags, Cloth Diaper Wet/Dry Bags, Pail Liners, Homemade Bags & More | Save Tons of Money Each Year While Meeting All Your Diverse Baby Care & Disposal Needs
- UNIVERSAL BABY DIAPER PAIL | Out of Sight, Out of Mind! Baby Diaper Disposal System Helps You Maintain a Neat, Clean, Fresh-Smelling Nursery Before Laundry or Garbage Day | Holds Up to 55 Individual Disposable Diapers, Reusable Cloth Diapers & Other Everyday Infant Waste & Recyclables for Mommy’s Convenience
- A MUST-HAVE FOR REGISTRY | Pamper New Parents with an Incredible Budget-Friendly Gift They Won’t Soon Forget! | Secure, Child-Proof Design is Not Only Smart But Safe, Making this Elegant Receptable an Ideal Gift for Baby Shower, Birthday, Christmas, Hannukah, Housewarming, Gender Reveal Party & So Much More
9. Diaper Pail Refills Fit Dekor Plus Diaper Pails - Powder Scent - Holds 4640 Diapers - 8 Pack
7.4/10 our score
- Perfect Compatibility: Compatible with all Dékor Plus Pails
- Large Capacity: Come with 8 Refills and holds up to 4640 newborn diapers
- Fresh Powder Scent: it helps keep your home smell fresh and clean
- High-Quality: 30% Thicker than the original one, making it more durable
- Convenience for Daily Cleanup: No need to waste time to change garbage bag every day, giving you more time to stay with your babies
10. Diaper Pail Refills Compatible with Diaper Genie Pails, Munchkin Step and Munchkin Pail,12 Pack
7.2/10 our score
- Compatible with Diaper Genie Expression, Diaper Genie Complete, Diaper Genie II, Diaper Genie II Elite, Diaper Genie Essentials and Mini. It is also compatible with Munchkin STEP and Munchkin PAIL
- Large Capacity: This compact refill comes with 3240 counts and holds up to 810 diapers
- Keep Odors Away: With unique barrier technology, each refill has the film to trap odors, making your home smell fresh and keep clean
- Cost Saving: Longer film in the cassette provide a more favorable cost for a longer lasting time
- Convenience for Daily Cleanup: No need to waste time to change garbage bag every day, giving you more time to stay with your babies