There is always a perfect best melatonin supplements out there in the market for you. However, you may not have the time and resources to try and research each of them in detail. So we’ve done the heavy lifting and are sharing below our detailed review of Top 10 best melatonin supplements.
In Hurry? Checkout Our Top Pick Of Best Melatonin Supplements.
Our Top Pick

9.7/10 our score
Best Melatonin Supplements
Rank | Product Name | Score |
---|---|---|
1 ![]() |
OLLY Restful Sleep Gummy Supplement |
9. 7 |
2 ![]() |
NOW Melatonin 5 mg |
9. 5 |
3 ![]() |
Natrol Melatonin Fast Dissolve Tablets |
9. 1 |
4 ![]() |
❶ Pharmaceutical Grade Melatonin by Just Potent :: 10mg Tablets :: Better Sleep :: Brain Health :: 120 Count :: Fast Acting and Non-Habit Forming Sleep Aid! |
8. 8 |
5 ![]() |
Puritan's Pride Super Strength Rapid Release Capsules |
8. 6 |
6 ![]() |
Nature Made Melatonin + with 200 Mg L-theanine |
8. 2 |
7 ![]() |
Natures Bounty Melatonin Quick Dissolve Tablet |
8. 0 |
8 ![]() |
Liquid Melatonin Sleep Aid by Bio Naturals - 100% Pure Sleeping Supplement with Inositol & L-Theanine Reduces Stress & Anxiety |
7 .7 |
9 ![]() |
Source Naturals Sleep Science Melatonin NutraSpray Sleep Support |
7. 4 |
10 ![]() |
GNC Melatonin 1 mg - Cherry |
7. 2 |
1. OLLY Restful Sleep Gummy Supplement

9.7/10 our score
- Olly Sleep gummy: our melatonin Gummies, with L-Theanine and botanicals like chamomile and lemon Balm, help boost your natural sleep hormone, encourage a calm feeling, and support a healthy sleep cycle, making it easier for you to fall asleep.
- Sweet dreams are made of these: at Olly, we want the same things as you, like steady energy, better sleep & feeling healthy. Nothing helps you feel your best like a good night's sleep, & Our sleep gummies help you drift off without chemical sleep aids.
- Naturally tasty gummies: why leave fun, chewable vitamins to Kids? When something feels good, you're more likely to do it & Nothing feels better than feeling healthy. Olly Gummy vitamins & gummy supplements make it easy & fun to get your daily dose.
- Hi there. We're Olly: we've made it our personal mission to make nutrition easy to understand, so you can pursue good health without compromise. Taking nutritional supplements shouldn't be a chore, which is why ours are just as effective as they are fun.
- Olly is different: try our vitamins and wellness boosts and discover for yourself how we're different. Olly Gummy vitamins, gummy supplements and protein powders are fun, easy and rewarding to fit into your daily nutritional and healthy lifestyle goals.
2. NOW Melatonin 5 mg

9.5/10 our score
- Free Radical Scavenger*
- Gastrointestinal Support*
- Healthy Sleep Cycle*
- GMP Quality Assured: NPA A-rated GMP certification means that every aspect of the NOW manufacturing process has been examined, including our laboratory/testing methods (for stability, potency, and product formulation).
- Packaged in the USA by a family owned and operated company since 1968
3. Natrol Melatonin Fast Dissolve Tablets

9.1/10 our score
- GET BETTER SLEEP – Melatonin is naturally produced by our bodies to manage sleep cycles, but its balance can be easily disrupted. Natrol Advanced Sleep Melatonin helps you fall asleep faster, stay asleep longer, and wake up feeling refreshed, plus, it’s 100% vegetarian.
- 100% DRUG FREE – Natrol Advanced Sleep Melatonin is a nighttime sleep aid that assists with occasional sleeplessness. This drug-free sleep aid means no morning grogginess. It is non-habit forming, so you can use it with confidence whenever you need to adjust your internal clock.
- BETTER OVERALL HEALTH – Natrol Melatonin helps to establish normal sleep patterns and give you a more restful and relaxing sleep and in turn, better overall health. Research shows that better sleep can lead to improved performance and focus.
- #1 MELATONIN BRAND IN AMERICA – Natrol is the #1 melatonin brand in America and one of the nation’s leading manufacturers of vitamins and supplements.
- FAST DISSOLVE TABLETS – Natrol’s unique fast dissolve strawberry formula enables faster absorption that can be taken anytime, anywhere. No water needed.
4. ❶ Pharmaceutical Grade Melatonin by Just Potent :: 10mg Tablets :: Better Sleep :: Brain Health :: 120 Count :: Fast Acting and Non-Habit Forming Sleep Aid!

8.8/10 our score
- Groggy-free morning, wake up happy, refreshed, and ready to take over the world
- With Just Potent Melatonin (10mg), your best night sleep awaits!
- Unadulterated and potent melatonin 10 mg
- Best melatonin supplement money can buy
5. Puritan's Pride Super Strength Rapid Release Capsules

8.6/10 our score
- Nighttime sleep aid
- Super strength
- Fall asleep quickly and stay asleep longer
- Fall asleep quickly and stay asleep longer
6. Nature Made Melatonin + with 200 Mg L-theanine

8.2/10 our score
- Make sure this fits by entering your model number.
- For a limited time, you may receive either bottle while we update our packaging. Both have the same great product inside. Based on new FDA regulations, you may also notice a change in the unit of measure and/or daily value for certain products.
- Contains a 60-day supply of Nature Made Melatonin 3 mg with 200 mg L-theanine Softgels, 60 softgels per bottle.
- Natural acting sleep aid. Helps relax the mind and support sleep.
- Adults, take 1 softgel one hour before bedtime with water.
- These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.
7. Natures Bounty Melatonin Quick Dissolve Tablet

8/10 our score
- Pack of 90 Quick Dissolve Tablets (Packed as 2 x 45 count bottles)
8. Liquid Melatonin Sleep Aid by Bio Naturals - 100% Pure Sleeping Supplement with Inositol & L-Theanine Reduces Stress & Anxiety

7.7/10 our score
- FALL ASLEEP FAST & PEACEFULLY – Are you having trouble falling asleep? Do you often wake up in the middle of the night? Bio Naturals 100% natural sleep aid supplement is here to help you relax and enjoy a full night’s sleep effortlessly!
- 100% NATURAL INGREDIENTS – Our new and advanced, fast absorbing, liquid formula is based on natural, organic, healthy and safe ingredients which have been known to promote a healthy sleep pattern and relieve stress.
- FAST-ACTING LIQUID FORMULA FOR SAFE & INSTANT RESULTS – Unlike tablets and pills, Bio Naturals sleep aid liquid formula will act 50% faster with 98% of the nutrients instantly absorbed by your body. Say goodbye to those sleepless nights with our fast & effective formula!
- FEEL MORE CONFIDENT, PRODUCTIVE & REJUVENATED – A good night’s sleep will not only help relieve stress and anxiety, but also turbo-charge your productivity, energy levels and cognitive function! And the best part? You’ll never experience that frustrating “hangover effect” other sleep aid supplements may cause.
- YOUR WELL-BEING IS OUR TOP PRIORITY – Bio Naturals stress-relieving and powerful sleeping aid is USA-made in FDA-registered facilities under strict guidelines. Rest assured that our formula contains no fillers, sugar, salt, gluten, dairy, soy or starch. And it also comes with our hassle-free, full refund guarantee.
9. Source Naturals Sleep Science Melatonin NutraSpray Sleep Support

7.4/10 our score
- NATURAL SLEEP AID - Source Naturals Melatonin is a non-habit forming solution that helps reset the body's internal clock for those with unusual work schedules or for those wanting relief from problems falling asleep and staying asleep. The normal cycles of melatonin production are altered due to factors including aging, medications, and light exposure at night. Something as small as travel, working nights or possibly using a computer screen may greatly impact melatonin’s production.
- BETTER SLEEP/WAKE UP REFRESHED - Healthy sleep not only supports better cognitive function and concentration, but it also supports immune function and vitality. Research has shown melatonin can help people help fall asleep more quickly, help travelers adjust to different time zones and helps night shift workers re-regulate their sleep. The better your sleep, the more likely you will wake up ready to seize the day!
- NO GROGGINESS/NON HABIT FORMING/SAFE - All natural, works the same way melatonin, the sleep hormone produced in the body, works so you won't wake up with a groggy, hungover feeling in the morning.
- EASILY ABSORBED/CONVENIENT SOLUTION - Our potent quick spray formula will help you fall asleep and achieve a full night's sleep. Fall asleep faster, stay asleep longer and achieve much needed rest. Our easy to spray delivery form is a perfect option for those who don't like to swallow pills.
- RESPONSIBLY MANUFACTURED - Our customers’ well-being is our highest priority. In everything we do, our guiding principle is to provide safe, superior quality products that enhance customers’ health and well-being. Both the raw materials and our finished products go through rigorous quality testing. You can rest assured knowing that Source Naturals was the first company to widely distribute melatonin in the US and we continue to deliver the very best.
10. GNC Melatonin 1 mg - Cherry

7.2/10 our score
- GNC Melatonin 1 MG supports quality sleep*
- Ideal for those experiencing occasional sleeplessness or jet lag, melatonin supports restful sleep,* so you can wake up feeling refreshed
- Each vegetarian lozenge provides 1mg of melatonin in great-tasting cherry flavor
- Contains no preservatives or artificial flavors or colors and is also soy-, yeast-, wheat-, gluten- and dairy-free
- *These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.